Indian Toilets vs Western Toilets – Pros, Cons & Which One’s Better for Your Health?

Let’s be honest—no one thought adulting would mean having passionate debates about… toilets. Yet here we are. Renovating bathrooms, scouting Pinterest boards, and googling “Indian toilet vs Western toilet” at 2 a.m. like it’s a life-altering decision

Choosing between the good Indian squat-style toilet and the modern, throne-like Western-style toilet is not just about looks. It’s about comfort, hygiene, space, budget, health, and yes, whether your grandma can use it without dislocating a hip.

So, whether you’re revamping your dream bathroom, building from scratch, or just trying to settle the great toilet war at home, this guide breaks it all down for you. We’re talking pros, cons, water usage, health angles, space, money, and everything in between.

Let’s flush the confusion and dive straight in!

Indian Toilet vs Western Toilet – A Quick Comparison

Feature	Indian Toilet (Squat Style)	Western Toilet (Seating Style)
Position	Squatting posture	Sitting posture
Comfort for the Elderly	Low – can be difficult to squat, especially with joint issues	High – easy to use for the elderly and people with mobility issues
Water Usage	Low – usually manual flush or bucket-based	Higher–tank–based flush uses more water
Installation Cost	Budget-friendly, minimal setup	Expensive – requires plumbing, flush tanks, fittings
Health Benefits	Promotes better digestion & natural bowel movement	More comfortable for long sitting, but not as health-optimized
Maintenance	Simple design, easy to clean, fewer moving parts	Needs regular cleaning (seat, hinges), more wear and tear
Space Requirement	Compact – great for small bathrooms	Takes up more space, especially with elongated bowl designs
Accessibility	Not friendly for disabled, elderly, or pregnant women	Designed with accessibility in mind – can add grab rails, etc.
Cultural Relevance	Deeply rooted in Indian tradition	Seen as modern and globally standard
Aesthetics	Basic look, practical	Sleek, designer-friendly, fits modern interiors

Best Bathroom Fittings Brands in India

Indian Toilets – Pros and Cons

Also known as squatting toilets or simply “Indian closets” (yep, that’s what they’re called in plumbing lingo), this humble setup has been around since the Indus Valley Civilization. If ancient civilizations trusted it, it must be doing something right, yeah?

Pros of Indian Toilets

1. Better Posture = Better Poop

Squatting naturally aligns your bowels, making it easier to, well, let go.
Research backs it: squatting reduces straining, prevents constipation, and may lower the risk of haemorrhoids. No kidding—this position is basically yoga for your gut.

2. Water-Saver Mode:

Since Indian toilets usually don’t have fancy flush tanks, they consume less water. Most people just use a mug and bucket combo.
It’s old-school, but honestly? Super sustainable.

3. No Butt-Seat Contact = Less Germ Anxiety

Hygiene-wise, there’s no direct contact with the toilet, which reduces the chances of transferring germs, especially useful in public spaces or large households.

4. Easy on the Wallet

Minimal plumbing, no fancy fittings, no imported ceramic. If you’re on a budget or building multiple bathrooms, Indian toilets cost significantly less to install and maintain.

5. Space-Saver

Tight bathroom? No problem. Indian toilets don’t demand much floor area, making them perfect for compact Indian homes or rental units.

Cons of Indian Toilets

1. The Elderly Curse: Bad Knees Beware

Let’s be real—squatting isn’t for everyone. Older adults, pregnant women, people with arthritis or knee injuries might find it hard (or downright impossible).

2. Too Much Effort?

You gotta squat. Balance. Then stand back up without grabbing onto your showerhead for support. It’s a workout. Great for your thighs, not so much when you’re sleepy at 2 am.

3. Manual Cleaning = Not Fun

Because of its low setup and water bucket system, you often need to clean manually, and that’s not everyone’s cup of chai. Especially in shared spaces.

4. Modern Bathroom Clash

If you’re going for a Pinteresty, spa-like bathroom vibe, Indian closets can feel outdated. Plus, they don’t pair well with fancy bidets or designer tiles.

Should you squat it out?

If you’re into traditional practices, budget-conscious, or want better digestion, Indian toilets win. But if accessibility and comfort are your top priorities, they might not be ideal for everyday use.

Best Bathroom Shower Designs

Western Toilets – Pros and Cons

Also called seating toilets, Western closets, or commodes, these are what you’ll find in most urban homes, airports, hotels, and bougie restaurants. They come with sleek designs, cozy seats, and all the bells and whistles—flush tanks, bidets, motion sensors… heck, even heated seats if you’re living the luxe life.

But is it all comfort and no cons? Let’s break it down.

Pros of Western Toilets

1. Ultimate Comfort for All Ages

Let’s face it—sitting is just easier. Whether you’re a child, an elderly parent, or someone nursing a sore knee, Western toilets offer effortless usage. No squatting acrobatics required.

2. Perfect for Accessibility

Western toilets are more adaptable for people with mobility issues, injuries, or disabilities. You can add grab bars, raised seats, and even automated flushing systems to make life easier. Big win for inclusive design.

3. Modern Features Galore

Want to add a bidet? Or a dual-flush system? Or even smart sensors? Western-style toilets are made for upgrades. They’re compatible with almost every modern sanitation innovation.

4. Stylish & Customisable

From wall-mounted designs to sleek ceramic finishes, Western commodes look fancy. They’re a solid match for contemporary interiors and minimalist aesthetics.

5. Easy to Clean (Kind Of)

Pop off the seat, wipe things down, flush, and go. With regular maintenance, Western toilets are hygienic and quick to clean, especially if you invest in self-cleaning or rimless models.

Cons of Western Toilets

1. More Water Wastage

Compared to Indian toilets, Western ones are notoriously water-hungry. Even with dual-flush systems, the tank flush mechanism uses more water per visit.

2. Expensive Installation & Maintenance

Let’s talk rupees. A Western toilet needs plumbing, a flush tank, fittings, and regular servicing. That’s extra on the installation and maintenance front.

3. Germ Concerns

Sitting directly on a toilet seat (especially in public washrooms) = more exposure to bacteria and viruses. You can clean it, yes, but there’s always that slight ick factor.

4. Takes Up More Space

Western toilets, especially elongated or tank-attached ones, eat up more real estate in your bathroom. In tiny Indian flats or older homes, this can be a squeeze.

5. Health Debate: Not the Best for Digestion?

Some studies suggest that the sitting posture doesn’t allow full bowel movement, which may contribute to constipation or other GI issues over time. So ironically, your throne might not be helping your… ahem, exit strategy.

So, is sitting the better option?
If your bathroom is modern, your family includes elders or kids, and comfort is your top priority, Western toilets are the clear winner. But don’t forget the water usage, cost, and health trade-offs.

Indian Toilet vs Western Toilet – Which One is Better?

Let’s be honest, this isn’t a one-size-fits-all (or one-style-fits-all) situation. Both toilet types come with their own perks and quirks, and the right pick really depends on who’s using it, where it’s being used, and how often.

For the Elderly, Pregnant Women, or People with Mobility Issues?

Prefer: Western Toilet
Standing, squatting, balancing—none of that is ideal for people with physical challenges. Western toilets, especially with grab bars or raised seats, are way more accessible and safe.

For Homes with Young Kids?

Prefer: Western Toilet (with supervision)
Young kids find it easier to use Western toilets, especially with a child toilet seat adapter. But cleanliness matters more here, so keep those seats wiped down!

For Health and Digestion?

Prefer: Indian Toilet
Multiple studies point out that the squatting posture is more natural for complete bowel evacuation. So if gut health is your top priority, Indian toilets have the edge.

For Budget-Friendly Bathrooms?

Prefer: Indian Toilet
No fancy flush tanks, no imported fittings, no plumber’s nightmare. Indian toilets are low-cost legends in both setup and long-term maintenance.

For Water-Saving?

Prefer: Indian Toilet
A mug, a bucket, and your aim—that’s all you need. Indian toilets use way less water, while Western toilets (even with dual flush) go heavy on H2O.

For Modern Homes or Luxury Bathrooms?

Prefer: Western Toilet
Got a chic home interior? Western toilets look cleaner and sleeker. Plus, they blend beautifully with vanity units, tiles, shower cabins, and bidet attachments.

For Compact Bathrooms?

Prefer: Indian Toilet
If you’re designing a small-space bathroom, Indian toilets take up less floor space and make tight layouts feel less claustrophobic.

For Shared/Public Bathrooms?

Prefer: Indian Toilet
When cleanliness is questionable, not having to sit is a huge plus. Indian toilets win the hygiene round in shared or public use cases.

Final Verdict?

Honestly? There’s no single “better” toilet—it’s about what works best for you.

If you’re building a modern home, have aging family members, or simply value comfort, Western is your best bet.
But if you’re eco-conscious, prefer low maintenance, or live in a traditional setup, Indian toilets bring unmatched practicality.

“It’s not just about East vs West. It’s about who uses it, how often, and what you prioritize—comfort, hygiene, or health.”

Expert Tip: Think Long-Term, Not Just Looks

Before picking between an Indian toilet and a Western one, ask yourself:

• Who’ll use it the most—kids, elders, guests, you?
• How often will it be used—daily or occasionally?
• Will your future bathroom needs change as the family grows or ages?
• Are you prioritising sustainability, accessibility, or style?

Many homeowners today actually install both—a Western commode in the master bath and an Indian toilet in the utility or guest bathroom. Best of both worlds, right?

Also, don’t ignore the quality of the brand, the flush mechanism, and plumbing compatibility. A poorly installed toilet—no matter the type—is a lifetime of regrets

Planning a Bathroom Renovation?

Planning a bathroom renovation? Explore the best Indian and Western toilet brands, space-saving designs, and expert tips at Propertygeek.

Whether you’re going full minimalistic with a wall-mounted Western closet or keeping it real with a traditional Indian squat pan—make sure your toilet fits your life, not just your bathroom.

Indian vs Western Toilets FAQs: